Getting paid
What can I do if my main contractor won't pay?
Start with the notices. If the main contractor did not serve a valid payment notice or pay less notice in time, the sum you applied for is usually the notified sum and is due in full. Put that in writing with a deadline. If it is still not paid you can give seven days' notice and suspend work, claim statutory interest and refer the dispute to adjudication. See payment disputes.
What is a pay less notice?
The notice a paying party must serve if it intends to pay less than the notified sum. It must state the amount it considers due and how that was worked out, and it must arrive before the deadline in the contract. Under the Scheme for Construction Contracts that is seven days before the final date for payment.
Is a pay less notice valid if it is late?
No. A late pay less notice has no effect, so the notified sum must be paid in full. The payer can argue about the value later in a true value adjudication, but only after paying. Our guide to pay less notices covers the other common defects.
Can I stop work if I am not paid?
Yes, if the notified sum is not paid by the final date for payment. Section 112 of the Construction Act lets you suspend some or all of your work after at least seven days' written notice stating the grounds. You are then entitled to an extension of time and your reasonable costs of suspending and restarting. Leaving site without following that process is risky.
Can the main contractor hold my payment until the client pays them?
Not usually. Pay when paid clauses are ineffective under the Construction Act unless the party above is insolvent, and payment cannot be made conditional on what happens under another contract.
How do I recover retention?
Work out when each half falls due under your subcontract, then apply for it in writing with evidence of completion or making good. If it is not paid and no valid pay less notice is served, you can recover it through adjudication. Retention tied to the main contract's completion may be challengeable. See retention recovery.
Can I charge interest on late payments?
Usually. If your contract does not provide a substantial remedy for late payment, the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 gives statutory interest at 8% above the Bank of England base rate, plus fixed compensation per invoice.
Adjudication
How does smash and grab adjudication work?
You refer the failure to pay the notified sum, not the value of the work. If your application was valid and no valid payment notice or pay less notice was served in time, the adjudicator orders payment of the sum applied for. Since S&T v Grove the paying party can start a true value adjudication, but only after it has paid.
How long does adjudication take?
The referral is served within seven days of the notice of adjudication, and the decision is due 28 days after the referral. The adjudicator can extend by 14 days with the referring party's consent, or longer if both parties agree. Allow five to seven weeks from notice to decision, plus preparation time beforehand.
How much does adjudication cost?
Our fees for a straightforward payment adjudication taken to a decision are £4,220 across three fixed stages. The adjudicator's fee is separate, commonly £3,000 to £8,000 for a payment dispute, and the decision says who pays it. Each side normally bears its own representation costs. Details are on our adjudication page.
Do I need a quantum expert for adjudication?
Not for a payment or notified sum dispute. For a final account or a large loss and expense claim, an independent quantum report can carry real weight. See expert witness.
I have received a notice of adjudication. What should I do?
Call us the same day. The referral will usually follow within seven days and you may have as little as seven days after that to respond. Check the notice for jurisdictional problems and reserve your position in writing straight away.
Delay, time and claims
How do I claim an extension of time as a subcontractor?
Give a written delay notice as soon as delay becomes apparent, identifying the cause. Follow it with particulars of the effect and an estimate of the delay, and keep it updated. The claim should show, from the programme and your records, how the event delayed your critical path. Check your subcontract for short notice periods. See delay and disruption claims.
What is the difference between delay and disruption?
Delay is about time, the work finishing later than it should. Disruption is about productivity, the work taking more effort than it should, even if completion does not move. They are claimed differently and need different records.
What evidence do I need for a delay claim?
The contract and your notices, the baseline programme and its updates, site diaries, photographs, minutes, RFIs and instructions, and labour and plant allocation sheets. For the cost, payroll, plant hire invoices and cost reports for the delay period. Records made at the time count for much more than anything prepared afterwards.
How do I claim loss and expense?
Under JCT, make a written application as soon as it becomes reasonably apparent that a Relevant Matter is causing you loss and expense, with supporting information, and update it regularly. The claim is based on what you actually spent and lost. See JCT subcontract claims.
How long do I have to notify a compensation event?
Eight weeks from becoming aware of the event under clause 61.3 of NEC3 and NEC4. Miss it and, for most events, there is no change to the Prices or the Completion Date. NEC subcontracts are often amended to shorten the period.
What is a compensation event?
The NEC mechanism for changing the Prices and the Completion Date when something happens that is not the Contractor's risk. The list is in clause 60.1 and includes changes to the Scope, late access, physical conditions, weather and the Client's own failures. They are assessed on Defined Cost plus the Fee. See NEC contract administration.
What is a final account?
The agreed total value of the work under the contract, including variations, compensation events, claims and other adjustments. Final accounts are one of the most common causes of disputes for subcontractors. See variations and final accounts.
Working with us
How much does a construction claims consultant cost?
In the UK, usually between £400 and £1,200 a day, depending on seniority and complexity. Our claims preparation rate is £450 a day, forensic delay analysis £730 and expert witness work £960. Adjudication is priced by fixed stage. Everything is on our fees page.
How much does an outsourced quantity surveyor cost?
Retained QS support for subcontractors starts at £1,690 a month for an agreed scope. One-off work is priced by the day or as a fixed fee. Across the market, outsourced QS work is typically £350 to £800 a day.
Can I use you for just one job?
Yes. A lot of our subcontractor work is a single package or final account. We agree the scope, quote a fee and stop when it is done.
Is the first conversation charged?
No. Call or send an enquiry and a senior consultant will talk it through with you. If we can help, you get a written fee proposal before any chargeable work starts.
Do you work on a no win, no fee basis?
No. It gives the consultant an interest in the size of the claim rather than whether it is sound. We would rather charge a fair fee and tell you when a claim is weak.
Where are you based and which areas do you cover?
Our office is at Izabella House, Regent Place, in Birmingham city centre. We work across the Midlands, including Solihull and Coventry, and UK wide, including Leeds and Yorkshire, Manchester and London. We have a base in Dubai for work in the Gulf.
Do you work outside the UK?
Yes. We work on FIDIC projects in the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, and support clients on projects in Europe and North America. See Middle East work.
Which contracts do you work with?
NEC3 and NEC4, including the ECS and ECSC subcontracts; JCT main contracts and subcontracts, including DBSub; FIDIC Red, Yellow and Silver Books, 1999 and 2017; and bespoke or heavily amended forms.
What qualifications should a claims consultant have?
Membership of a recognised body such as the RICS, CIOB or CICES, and real experience of the contract form your dispute sits under. Ask who will personally do the work and what they have done on contracts like yours. Our team includes chartered quantity surveyors (MRICS), a member of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators and an RICS Accredited Mediator.
What is the difference between a QS and a commercial manager?
A QS traditionally focuses on measurement, valuation and cost. A commercial manager covers that plus contract administration, claims, risk and the overall financial result of the project. On most jobs the roles overlap. We provide both, and the level depends on what you need.
Do you help with tenders and pre-qualification?
Yes. We help subcontractors price tenders, set out sensible qualifications and complete pre-qualification questionnaires, including Constructionline and Achilles UVDB.
