Delay claims are won or lost on two things: whether the right notices went in at the right time, and whether the programme evidence links the event to the late finish. Get both right and most delay disputes settle. Get either wrong and the other side will spend its time on that, not on what actually happened.
We prepare delay and disruption claims for specialist subcontractors and main contractors, and we analyse claims made against employers. Programme analysis and quantum are done in-house, so the time and the money tell the same story.
Delay and disruption are different claims
People use the words together, but they are not the same thing, and they need different evidence.
Delay
The work finishes later than it should. The claim is for more time, an extension of time, and for the cost of being on site longer.
Disruption
The work takes more effort than it should. Productivity drops even if the completion date does not move. The claim is for the lost productivity.
You can have one without the other. A gang moved between three areas because access was not ready may finish on time but use twice the hours. That is disruption, and it is often the larger claim for a subcontractor.
Extension of time claims for subcontractors
An extension of time claim for a subcontractor has an extra layer. Your subcontract programme sits inside the main contractor's, and the main contractor's own failures are often what is delaying you: late access, trades not finished ahead of you, design information not issued. Those are usually your grounds for an extension, not just events caused by the employer.
The first step is always the delay notice. Most subcontracts require you to notify as soon as delay becomes apparent, and amended subcontracts often set a short fixed period. A notice that is late, vague or missing gives the main contractor an easy answer. We draft notices that state the cause, the work affected and the likely effect, even when the effect is not yet known.
Critical path analysis and programme impact assessment
To get time, you need to show the event delayed the critical path to completion. Showing that it delayed something is not enough. That means looking at the programme properly.
The Society of Construction Law Delay and Disruption Protocol sets out the recognised methods. The right one depends on the records available and whether the project is still live.
- Time impact analysis. The event is modelled into the programme current at the time. The best method for live projects and the one the SCL Protocol prefers for contemporaneous assessment.
- Impacted as-planned. Events added to the original programme. Quick, but easily criticised if the plan was never realistic.
- As-planned versus as-built. Comparing what was planned with what happened, activity by activity. Good where the as-built records are strong.
- Windows analysis. The project broken into periods and the critical path tracked through each one. Usually the most persuasive retrospective method on a complex job.
Our SCL Protocol delay analysis uses the method your records will support, and as a delay analysis consultant we will explain why we chose it. A sophisticated method on poor records does more harm than a simple method on good ones.
Concurrent delay
Concurrent delay means two causes of delay, one yours and one theirs, affecting completion at the same time. Under English law the usual position is that you get the extension of time but not the money for the period of true concurrency. Contracts can change that. In North Midland Building v Cyden Homes [2018] the Court of Appeal upheld a clause saying concurrent delay would not count towards an extension at all.
True concurrency is less common than people claim. The SCL Protocol says so, and so do most adjudicators. When a main contractor raises it, we test whether its own delay was genuinely critical at the same time, or just a convenient argument.
Prolongation costs claims
A prolongation costs claim covers the time-related cost of being on site longer: supervision, site establishment, plant on hire, welfare and so on. It should be based on what was actually spent during the delay period, not on the preliminaries in your tender.
Head office overheads can be recovered too, but only if you can show you lost the opportunity to earn them elsewhere. Formulae such as Hudson and Emden are used to calculate the figure. They do not prove the loss on their own.
Loss of productivity claims
A loss of productivity claim compares how efficiently you worked when you were disrupted with how efficiently you worked when you were not. The SCL Protocol favours a measured mile analysis, where the undisrupted period on the same job is the benchmark. It needs good allocation records. If you keep labour hours by area and activity, the claim almost writes itself.
Acceleration costs
If you were instructed to speed up, or you were refused an extension you were entitled to and had to throw resources at the job to avoid damages, the extra cost may be recoverable. Under NEC4 acceleration is agreed by quotation under clause 36. Under JCT it usually needs an instruction or a separate agreement. Without one, an acceleration claim is much harder, so put your position in writing before you spend the money.
Loss and expense claims and EOT claims under JCT
Under JCT, time and money are separate. An EOT claim under JCT runs through the Relevant Events, and a loss and expense claim through the Relevant Matters, with separate notices. Getting the extension does not automatically get you paid for it. Our page on JCT subcontract claims covers both.
Questions
What is the difference between delay and disruption?
Delay is about time: the work finishing later than it should. Disruption is about efficiency: the work taking more labour and plant than it should, whether or not the finish date moves. They are claimed differently and need different evidence.
What evidence do I need for a delay claim?
The contract and every delay notice, the baseline programme and its updates, site diaries, progress photographs, minutes of meetings, RFIs and instructions, and labour and plant allocation sheets. For the cost side you need payroll, plant hire invoices and your cost reports for the delay period. Records made at the time carry far more weight than anything put together later.
Is a delay notice a condition precedent?
It depends on the wording. Standard JCT notices are not usually drafted as conditions precedent, though failing to give one can still reduce what you recover. Many amended subcontracts and the NEC eight-week rule do operate as time bars. Assume your notice matters until someone has read the clause.
Do you do the programme analysis yourselves?
Yes. Delay analysis and quantum are both done in-house. Where the dispute needs an independent delay expert, we can provide one.
