Construction claims and commercial consultants · Birmingham and Dubai
RKA Associates
  1. Home
  2. Services
  3. Variations and final accounts
Variations and final accounts

Unpaid variations and final account disputes

Unpaid variations are the most common reason a subcontractor's final account ends up in dispute. We value the changes properly, prove they were instructed and negotiate the account to a close, or take it to adjudication when negotiation stops working.

  • Variation accounts rebuilt
  • Daywork claims
  • Negotiation or adjudication

Speak to a consultant

A senior consultant will reply within 48 hours, usually sooner, with a view on where you stand and what it would cost to take further.

We only use these details to reply to you. See our privacy notice.

Most final account disputes are not one big argument. They are fifty small ones: variations instructed on site and never confirmed, daywork sheets that were not signed, measured work valued at the wrong rate, and contra charges nobody can explain. Each one is easy to dismiss on its own. Together they are often a large part of your margin.

We rebuild the account item by item, prove what can be proved and present it so the main contractor has to engage with it.

Why variations go unpaid

The reasons are nearly always the same.

  • The instruction was verbal, from a site manager, and never confirmed in writing.
  • The subcontract required notice within a set period and none was given.
  • The work was done before it was priced, and the price came months later.
  • The main contractor says the work was in your original scope.
  • The records do not show what was actually done, or how long it took.

Most of these can be dealt with if the facts are on your side. A verbal instruction can be proved by emails, minutes, photographs and the fact that the main contractor watched you do the work. A scope argument is answered by the subcontract documents, not by what the main contractor's QS remembers.

What counts as a variation claim

A variation order in construction is a change to the work described in the subcontract: different design, extra quantities, changed sequence, different access or working hours, or work omitted. Under JCT it is valued under the Valuation Rules. Under NEC it is a compensation event, usually under clause 60.1(1), assessed on Defined Cost plus the Fee. The route matters, because the notice requirements and the basis of valuation are different.

Instruction and change claims

Not every change comes with an instruction. Some arise from late information, design development or the main contractor changing the sequence without saying so. These instruction and change claims are often worth more than the formal variations, and they are the ones most likely to be time-barred if nobody is watching. We review the subcontract for the notice provisions and help clients set up a simple register, so nothing is missed on the next job.

Valuation of variations

The valuation of variations follows a hierarchy in most contracts: your subcontract rates where the work is similar, rates based on them where it is not, and fair rates or daywork where neither works. Main contractors often apply your rates to work that is not similar at all, because it is cheaper. We test the conditions under which the work was carried out against the conditions you priced, and value accordingly.

Daywork claims

Daywork is the most argued part of many final accounts. A daywork claim needs signed sheets, issued promptly, showing names, hours, plant and materials against an instruction. The rates and percentages in the subcontract apply, often using the RICS or CECA definitions of prime cost. Unsigned sheets are not worthless, but they need other evidence behind them.

Final account negotiation

A disputed variation account rarely settles in one meeting. We prepare a clear account summary with every item referenced to evidence, and a schedule showing your figure, the main contractor's figure and the reason for the difference. That turns a general argument into a list of specific points, and specific points can be agreed.

We will also tell you where your account is weak. Conceding the items you cannot prove makes the rest of the account far more credible.

Final account dispute options

If negotiation stalls, the options are adjudication, which gives a binding decision in weeks, or court or arbitration where the sums are large or the issues complex. A final account subcontractor adjudication needs careful preparation because of the volume of evidence, and an independent quantum report can make a real difference. We handle both, and our adjudication page explains the costs.

Questions

Can I claim for a variation without a written instruction?

Often, yes. The question is whether the main contractor instructed or accepted the work, and that can be proved by emails, minutes, site diaries, photographs and conduct. Check the subcontract for any requirement that instructions must be in writing and any notice period, because those affect how strong the claim is.

How long should a final account take to agree?

Most subcontracts set a period after completion for the final account to be submitted and agreed, often a few months. In practice many drag on for a year or more. If yours has stalled, a clear account with evidence and a set deadline usually moves it.

The main contractor says the extra work was in my scope. What now?

Go back to the subcontract documents: the scope, drawings, specification and any tender qualifications. If the work is not described there, it is a variation. We review the documents and set out the scope argument in writing.

A final account that will not close?

Send us the account and the main contractor's last offer. We will tell you where the gap is and what can be done about it.