A claim is not a request for more money. It is a case that you are entitled to more money, or more time, under the contract you signed. The ones that get paid are the ones that show the event, the contract mechanism, the effect and the cost, in that order, with the records to back each step.
As construction claims consultants we prepare claims for specialist subcontractors and main contractors, and we assess claims for employers. Acting for both sides is useful. We know which arguments an assessor will reject in the first five minutes.
Start with whether the claim is worth bringing
Every claim we take on starts with a case viability assessment. We read the contract, the notices and the correspondence, look at the records you have, and tell you three things.
- Whether you have entitlement, and under which clause.
- Roughly what the claim is worth, as a range, with the weak parts identified.
- What it would cost to prepare and pursue, and whether that cost makes sense.
This claim entitlement assessment is a fixed fee of £510. Sometimes the honest answer is that the claim is time-barred, or that the records will not support the figure you have in mind. It is better to hear that now than after a year of argument.
Entitlement first, then quantum
Most weak claims start with the number and work backwards. Assessors can spot it immediately. We build the claim the other way round.
- The event. What happened, when, and who was responsible for it under the contract.
- The mechanism. The clause that gives you a right to time or money, and whether its conditions were met, including any notice requirements.
- The effect. What the event did to your work. Delay to the critical path, disruption to productivity, extra work or changed sequence.
- The cost. What that effect actually cost you, from your records, not your tender allowances.
Construction claim quantification
Quantum is where many claims lose most of their value. A head of claim that cannot be traced to a cost record will usually be valued at nothing. We quantify from first principles using your timesheets, allocation sheets, plant records, invoices and accounts.
The usual heads of claim are prolongation costs, disruption and loss of productivity, the cost of extra or changed work, acceleration costs, head office overheads, and finance charges where the contract allows them. Each one needs its own evidence, and we will tell you where yours is thin before the other side does.
Global claims, and why they are a last resort
A global claim lumps several events together and claims the total overrun without linking each cost to each cause. The courts have accepted them in principle. In Walter Lilly v Mackay [2012] the court confirmed a global claim can succeed, but only if the claimant proves the loss would not have happened anyway because of something it was responsible for itself.
That is a hard thing to prove, and one significant cause on your side can sink the whole claim. We use a global approach only for the part of a claim where the events genuinely cannot be separated, and we link everything else event by event.
Claims under NEC, JCT and FIDIC
The principles are the same across the forms, but the mechanisms and the time limits are not.
- NEC3 and NEC4. Claims are compensation events. The Contractor must notify within eight weeks of becoming aware under clause 61.3, and quotations are assessed on Defined Cost plus the Fee. See our page on NEC contract administration.
- JCT. Time comes through Relevant Events and money through Relevant Matters for loss and expense. Notices must be given when delay becomes reasonably apparent. See JCT subcontract claims.
- FIDIC. Under the 2017 editions a Notice of Claim is due within 28 days and the fully detailed claim within 84 days, under clause 20.2. See FIDIC claims.
Amended subcontracts often shorten these periods or add new conditions. Check yours before relying on the standard form.
Subcontractor claim preparation
Subcontractors face problems a main contractor does not. You may depend on the main contractor to pass your claim up the line, your records may be held by them, and your subcontract may be amended to make the main contractor's own entitlement a condition of yours. We deal with that daily, and we know how to present a subcontractor claim so it cannot simply be parked until the main contractor's account is settled.
Contractor claims support and claim defence
For main contractors we prepare claims to the employer, often combining several subcontractor claims with the contractor's own. For employers and their advisers we assess incoming claims and set out what is valid, what is not and why. Construction contract claims advice works best early, while there is still time to give the right notices.
Records that make a claim
- The contract and every notice sent and received
- Programmes, as planned and as updated
- Site diaries, daily reports and photographs
- Labour and plant allocation sheets
- Instructions, RFIs and minutes of meetings
- Cost reports and invoices
Questions
How long does it take to prepare a construction claim?
A single compensation event or variation claim can take a few days. A full delay and disruption claim on a large project can take two or three months, mostly spent on the records. The fixed fee review will give you a realistic timescale for yours.
Do I need a claims consultant or a solicitor?
For most claims, a claims consultant. The work is mostly commercial and technical: reading the contract, analysing the programme and proving the cost. Solicitors come in when a claim moves towards litigation or arbitration, or raises a difficult legal point. We work alongside solicitors regularly and will tell you when you need one.
Can you help if I missed a notice deadline?
Sometimes. Not every notice provision is a condition precedent, some events are excluded from the time bar, and the other side may have waived the requirement by its conduct. It depends entirely on the wording, so send us the contract and the dates.
Do you work on a no win, no fee basis?
No. A contingency fee gives the consultant an interest in the size of the claim rather than whether it is sound. We would rather charge a fair fee and tell you when a claim is weak.
