Construction claims and commercial consultants · Birmingham and Dubai
RKA Associates
  1. Home
  2. Services
  3. Retention recovery
Retention

Retention recovery for subcontractors

Retention recovery for subcontractors who have finished the work, waited the defects period and still not been paid. We check what the subcontract really says, apply for it properly and take it further when the main contractor sits on it.

  • Release dates checked
  • Pay less notices tested
  • Adjudication if needed

Speak to a consultant

A senior consultant will reply within 48 hours, usually sooner, with a view on where you stand and what it would cost to take further.

We only use these details to reply to you. See our privacy notice.

Retention is your money. It is held back as security for defects, not as a bonus for the main contractor's cash flow. Yet retention not released on time is one of the most common complaints we hear from subcontractors, and many write it off because chasing it seems more trouble than it is worth.

It is usually recoverable. The rules that protect interim payments apply to retention too.

How retention on construction contracts normally works

Most subcontracts hold back between 3% and 5% of the value of each payment. Typically half is released at practical completion and the other half at the end of the defects or rectification period, often 12 months later. The exact trigger, the percentage and the period are in your subcontract, and they are often amended from the standard form.

Retention on practical completion is where the trouble starts. Your subcontract may say your first half is released on completion of your own works, or on practical completion of the main contract, which may be months later. The difference matters.

Release dates tied to the main contract

A lot of subcontracts tie retention release to events under the main contract: the employer's practical completion certificate, the certificate of making good or the end of the main contract defects period. If you finished early in the job, that can mean waiting years.

Since 2011 the Construction Act has prevented payment being conditional on the performance of obligations under another contract. Whether a particular retention clause is caught depends on its wording, but many are. It is worth checking before you accept that you have to wait for the main contract to finish.

Retention release disputes and pay less notices

When retention falls due, it is a payment like any other. If you apply for it and the main contractor neither pays nor serves a valid pay less notice, the amount applied for is the notified sum. You can adjudicate for it on that basis, without arguing about defects.

Main contractors often hold retention against defects in other trades, or against their own disputes with the employer. Unless the subcontract allows it and a valid notice was served, that is not a reason to withhold yours.

How to recover retention from a main contractor

  1. Work out when each half fell due under the subcontract, and whether the trigger is enforceable.
  2. Apply for release in writing, with the evidence of completion or making good.
  3. Check whether a payment notice or pay less notice was served in time.
  4. Put the main contractor on notice of the sum due and the final date for payment.
  5. If it is still not paid, refer it to adjudication, or add it to a wider final account adjudication.

Many retention claims are small on their own. They become worth pursuing when several jobs with the same main contractor are added together, or when retention is part of a final account that is already in dispute.

If the main contractor is insolvent

In most subcontracts retention is not ring-fenced. If the main contractor goes into administration or liquidation before releasing it, you are usually an unsecured creditor for the amount. That is why we encourage clients to diarise every release date and chase it the day it falls due. If you are negotiating a new subcontract, a retention bond or a lower percentage is worth asking for.

Questions

How do I recover retention?

Apply in writing when it falls due, with evidence of completion or making good. If the main contractor does not pay or serve a valid pay less notice, the sum applied for becomes due and can be recovered through adjudication. Our retention recovery guide goes into more detail.

When should retention be released?

Whenever your subcontract says. Typically half at practical completion and half at the end of the defects period. If the subcontract ties release to the main contract, check whether that clause is enforceable under the Construction Act.

Can the main contractor keep my retention for other trades' defects?

Not usually. Retention is security for your own defects. Holding it against someone else's problems needs clear wording in the subcontract and a valid pay less notice.

Is it worth chasing small amounts of retention?

Often, especially when several jobs with the same main contractor are added together. Statutory interest can also be claimed on late payments where the contract does not provide a substantial remedy.

Retention still not released?

Send us the subcontract and the dates. We will tell you when it fell due and what you can do about it.