FIDIC claims are lost on procedure more often than on merit. The notice periods are short, many of them are conditions precedent, and particular conditions in the Gulf often make them shorter still. A good claim notified a few days late can be worth nothing.
Our team has worked on FIDIC contracts in the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, on infrastructure, water, aviation, rail and building projects, and has given evidence as a quantum and delay expert in dispute board and international arbitration proceedings.
FIDIC notice of claim requirements
Under the 2017 editions, clause 20.2 sets out a strict sequence.
- Notice of Claim within 28 days of becoming aware, or when you should have become aware, of the event (20.2.1).
- Engineer's initial response. If the Engineer thinks the notice is late, it must say so within 14 days, or the notice is deemed valid (20.2.2).
- Fully detailed Claim within 84 days, including the contractual or legal basis. If that basis is not submitted in time, the Notice of Claim is deemed to have lapsed (20.2.4).
- Agreement or determination by the Engineer under clause 3.7, with its own time limits.
The 1999 editions use clause 20.1: notice within 28 days, a fully detailed claim within 42 days and a response from the Engineer within 42 days. The 28-day notice is a condition precedent in both editions. Our guide to FIDIC claims notice requirements covers the detail and recent case law.
FIDIC Red Book claims
The Red Book is used where the employer designs the works and the contractor builds them, usually measured and valued against a bill of quantities. Most claims arise from variations, remeasurement, late drawings or instructions and unforeseeable physical conditions. The Engineer administers the contract and determines claims, so the quality of the submission to the Engineer matters a great deal.
FIDIC Yellow Book claims
Under the Yellow Book the contractor designs to the Employer's Requirements. Disputes often turn on what the requirements actually required, errors in them, and whether a change was a variation or design development. Yellow Book claims need the design history as well as the site records.
FIDIC Silver Book claims
The Silver Book is an EPC turnkey form, and it puts much more risk on the contractor. There is no independent Engineer. The Employer's Representative administers the contract and the Employer makes determinations. The contractor generally carries the risk of ground conditions and of errors in the employer's requirements. Silver Book claims are narrower, so the ones that exist must be notified and argued precisely.
FIDIC time and cost claims
Time and cost claims under FIDIC need the same things as anywhere else: cause, effect on the critical path and proven cost. Clause 8.5 sets out the grounds for an extension of time, and the programme under clause 8.3 is the baseline. We prepare delay analysis to the SCL Protocol and quantify cost from your records, in a form the Engineer, a DAAB or an arbitral tribunal will accept.
FIDIC claims in Dubai, Saudi Arabia and Qatar
Most of the contracts we see in the Gulf are FIDIC based, often the 1999 editions with extensive particular conditions, and increasingly the 2017 editions on newer projects. Local law can affect how time bars, liquidated damages and termination provisions are applied, so on contentious matters we work alongside local lawyers.
- FIDIC claims in Dubai and the UAE. Infrastructure, real estate, aviation and rail.
- FIDIC claims in Saudi Arabia. Giga-projects and major infrastructure, including PIF-backed programmes.
- FIDIC claims in Qatar. Infrastructure and building, including sports venues.
For more on our Gulf work, see our page as a Middle East construction claims consultant.
Questions
Is the 28-day FIDIC notice a condition precedent?
Yes, under both the 1999 and 2017 editions, unless the particular conditions change it. Under the 2017 editions the Engineer must raise lateness within 14 days, otherwise the notice is deemed valid, but you should not rely on that. Local law in some jurisdictions can also affect how strictly the bar is applied.
What goes in a FIDIC fully detailed claim?
A description of the event, the contractual or legal basis of the claim, the contemporary records relied on and the detailed supporting particulars of the time and money claimed. Under the 2017 editions it is due within 84 days of becoming aware of the event.
Can you help with a DAAB referral?
Yes. We prepare referrals and responses to Dispute Avoidance and Adjudication Boards, and our team includes a former dispute board member who has given expert evidence before them.
