Construction claims and commercial consultants · Birmingham and Dubai
RKA Associates
  1. Home
  2. Services
  3. Payment disputes
Payment disputes

Subcontractor not paid? Payment disputes under the Construction Act

If you are a subcontractor not paid what you applied for, the Construction Act gives you more protection than most main contractors would like you to know. We check the notices, work out what is legally due and get it paid.

  • Notices checked within days
  • Smash and grab adjudication
  • Fixed fee stages

Speak to a consultant

A senior consultant will reply within 48 hours, usually sooner, with a view on where you stand and what it would cost to take further.

We only use these details to reply to you. See our privacy notice.

When a main contractor is withholding payment, the first question is not whether they are right about the work. It is whether they followed the payment process. In a large number of the disputes we see, they did not, and the full amount of the application is due regardless of what they think it is worth.

That is the effect of the payment rules in the Construction Act. They apply to almost every construction contract in the UK, and any contract term that does not comply is replaced by the Scheme for Construction Contracts.

Your payment rights under the Construction Act

The Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, as amended in 2011, sets out the Construction Act payment rights that apply to your subcontract. In short:

  • You are entitled to interim payments, with a due date and a final date for payment.
  • The payer must say what it is going to pay, and how it worked that out, in a payment notice.
  • If it wants to pay less than the notified sum, it must serve a pay less notice in time.
  • If the notified sum is not paid by the final date, you can suspend work after seven days' notice.
  • Pay when paid clauses are ineffective, except where an upstream party is insolvent.

Where your subcontract does not provide for these things, the Scheme for Construction Contracts does. Contracts with a residential occupier are the main exception.

Payment notice, default payment notice and the notified sum

The paying party must serve a payment notice within five days of the due date, stating the sum it considers due and the basis of the calculation. If it does not, the position depends on your contract. Under many subcontracts your application stands as the payment notice. Under others you can serve a default payment notice yourself.

Either way, the result is a notified sum. That is the amount the payer must pay by the final date, unless it serves a valid pay less notice.

Pay less notices, and when a challenge works

A pay less notice has to be served no later than the prescribed period before the final date for payment. Where the contract is silent, the Scheme sets that at seven days. It must state the sum the payer considers due and the basis on which it was calculated.

A pay less notice challenge succeeds more often than people expect. The common faults are:

  • It was served late, even by a day.
  • It was sent to the wrong person or by a method the contract does not allow.
  • It gives a figure but no basis for it, or the basis cannot be followed.
  • It is really a payment notice, served at the wrong time, relabelled.

An invalid pay less notice is no pay less notice at all. The notified sum is due in full, and you can adjudicate to recover it without arguing about the value of the work. That is a smash and grab adjudication. See our guide to pay less notices for the detail.

Pay when paid and other illegal payment clauses

Section 113 of the Act makes a pay when paid clause ineffective unless the party above the payer is insolvent. Since 2011 the Act also prevents payment being made conditional on what happens under another contract. That catches many "pay when certified" clauses, which tie your payment to the main contractor's certificate from the employer.

Where a clause like that is struck out, the Scheme provisions take its place. We see illegal payment clauses in bespoke subcontracts regularly, and they are worth checking before you accept that you have to wait.

Contra charges and liquidated damages disputes

A contra charge is still a deduction from the notified sum, so it needs a valid pay less notice. Beyond that, the main contractor usually has to show that the work was your responsibility, that you were told and given the chance to put it right, and that the cost is reasonable. Many contra charges fall away once those questions are asked. Our guide to contra charges explains how.

A liquidated damages dispute is usually really an extension of time dispute. If you were entitled to more time, the damages fall away with it. That is why delay notices matter so much.

Suspension for non-payment

If the notified sum is not paid by the final date, section 112 lets you suspend all or part of your work. You must give at least seven days' written notice of your intention, stating the grounds. Once you suspend, you are entitled to an extension of time for the suspension period and your reasonable costs of stopping and restarting.

Suspension is a lawful right with a set process. Walking off site without following it is a different thing, and can leave you in breach of contract. See our page on termination and walking off site.

Late payment interest in construction

If your contract does not provide a substantial remedy for late payment, the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 adds statutory interest at 8% above the Bank of England base rate, plus a fixed sum of £40, £70 or £100 per invoice depending on its size. Many subcontracts include a lower contractual rate. Whether that rate is a substantial remedy is often worth arguing.

How we handle a construction payment dispute

  1. We check the dates: application, due date, payment notice, pay less notice and final date.
  2. We tell you what is legally due and whether the notices hold up.
  3. We write to the main contractor setting out the position and the deadline.
  4. If it is not paid, we serve a notice of intention to suspend or start adjudication, depending on what suits you.
  5. If a decision is not paid, we support enforcement.

Most disputes are settled at step three or four, once the main contractor realises the notices do not hold up.

Questions

What is a pay less notice?

It is the notice a paying party must serve if it intends to pay less than the notified sum. It must state the amount it considers due and how that was calculated, and it must be served before the deadline in the contract, or seven days before the final date for payment under the Scheme.

Is a pay less notice valid if it is late?

No. A pay less notice served after the deadline has no effect, and the notified sum must be paid in full. The paying party can still argue about the value of the work later, in a true value adjudication, but only after it has paid.

Can I stop work if I am not paid?

Yes, if the notified sum has not been paid by the final date for payment. Give at least seven days' written notice of your intention to suspend, stating why. You then get an extension of time and the reasonable costs of suspending.

What can I do if my main contractor won't pay?

Check whether valid notices were served, then put the main contractor on notice in writing. If that does not work, you can suspend for non-payment, claim statutory interest and refer the dispute to adjudication. Most cases do not need to go all the way.

Can the main contractor hold my money until the client pays them?

Not usually. Pay when paid clauses are ineffective under the Construction Act except where the client is insolvent, and payment cannot be made conditional on what happens under the main contract.

Payment due and nothing has arrived?

Send us the application, any notice you received and the subcontract. We will tell you within a couple of days what is legally due.